When repair makes sense
Repair is usually the first option for isolated leaks, limited missing shingles, newer roofs, or small flashing problems.
When replacement becomes practical
Replacement becomes more practical when the roof is old, brittle, repeatedly leaking, storm-damaged across multiple slopes, or expensive to keep patching.
Get both options in writing
A useful inspection should explain both the repair path and the replacement path, including risks, expected lifespan, and scope differences.